Sunday, 2 August 2020

The Sun changes earth's climate, not plant food.

Changes in the sun's activity cause earthquakes. Earthquakes happen around tectonic plate junctions, in the same place where volcanoes happen. If solar activity alters behaviour around tectonic plates it must affect volcanism too. Volcanoes cool earth's climate by ejecting tiny particles into the upper atmosphere which reflect sunlight away from earth. The last time we saw it dramatically was 29 years ago with the eruption of Mount Pinatubo, the second largest volcanic eruption of the 20th century. It cooled the Northern hemisphere by at least ½°C, for more than 1 year.

"In this paper, we analyze 20 years of proton density and velocity data, as recorded by the SOHO satellite, and the worldwide seismicity in the corresponding period, as reported by the ISC-GEM catalogue. We found clear correlation between proton density and the occurrence of large earthquakes (M> 5.6), with a time shift of one day. The signifcance of such correlation is very high, with with probability to be wrong lower than 10-5 " [meaning one in 10000] ... In this paper, we demonstrate that it [the correlation] can likely be due to the efect of solar wind, modulating the proton density and hence the electrical potential between the ionosphere and the Earth ... our hypothesis only implies that the proton density would act as a further, small trigger to cause the fracture on already critically charged faults, thus producing the observed large scale earthquake correlation."

Links: Salon | Nature (paper, open access)

Note: Volcanos also happen at seismic fault lines.

Why "climate science" is not good science.

Keywords: Hypothesis, hypothesis testing, scientific method, null hypothesis, testable hypothesis, scientific hypothesis

Greenhouse effect

AKA Greenhouse gas effect, GHGE, was never formulated as a scientific, testable hypothesis. It is pre-science, not science, a thought experiment, or model, currently summarized in (mainly) 2 papers: Manabe & Wetherald 1967, and Held & Soden 2000. Using a model of how they think the atmosphere works, plus calculations from those papers GHGE supporters calculate their greenhouse gas warming effect. The details of this calculation are obscured because its supporters never discuss nor debate it. They call it "settled science" or "basic physics". In fact it is neither science nor physics. This is the basic lie at the heart of climate doom propaganda.

GHGE is not even a scientific hypothesis because it is not validated. There aren't even any rigorous tests proposed for it. There are many alternative ways the calculation can be done using other models of how the atmosphere behaves. I can think of 4 models which calculate a negligible "greenhouse gas effect" because their model of atmospheric behaviour is different. In science, we decide between competing models of how something works by formulating each as a "testable hypothesis". The "hypothesis" part is the explanation for it. The "testable" part is the proof of the pudding. Supporters and critics of a hypothesis should formulate real world experiments to test the idea. Every valid test must pass, meaning the predicted hypothesis results must agree with experiment and observation. If any single test fails, the hypothesis is abandoned or reformulated.

So far, greenhouse gas effect supporters have succeeded by corrupting science. They by-passed the "testable hypothesis" requirement for science and just declared their idea "settled science".

"climate science"

Before it became "climate science", the study of climate was called climatology. Modelers behind the greenhouse gas effect renamed their work as "climate science" because it wasn't any kind of science at all. It was modeling. Not very good modeling either because the modelers ride roughshod over rules for making good forecasts. Science involves empirical observation and/or experiment done under controlled conditions. At its worst: modeling is just making stuff up.

Alternatives to 'consensus' GHGE model:

How to argue with climate alarmists

1. Stop bandying insults with them. It does not help. Insults help neither you, by-standers, nor lefties. It annoys people. Bystanders will mute you to stop you boring them.

To be clear: never insult them - even when they provoke you. It distracts you (from your aim of presenting the evidence). It makes you look bad in the eyes of neutrals. It makes you feel bad in your own minds-eye. Insults harm you more than they harm your opponent. This isn't a Christian thing = be meek; it's a rationalist thing - use reason.

2. Ask them for their evidence. In fact: demand: evidence, evidence, evidence. Or demand they evaluate your evidence.

They will, most likely, give you some general statements. Don't accept generalities from them as evidence. Generalities are never evidence; they are conclusions. Demand specifics.

Lefties (Wokes, climate alarmists and Marxians) think in generalities. For example:

  • all men are sexist
  • all whites are racist
  • all climate change is the fault of humans
  • everything bad in society is due to capitalism

This is why we should ask for specific evidence, such as an actual example. It forces the alarmist to think and even question themselves about whether they really understand anything. If they cannot give a specific, clear example of something it becomes harder for them to generalize about everything. Then they begin to wonder whether they are right or wrong.

Don't let them distract you with: insults, bluster, projection, argument from authority, whataboutery and red-herrings. Stick to your point. Force them to at least say yay or nay to your evidence.

Discipline yourself. Discuss one issue at a time. Don't let them make the discussion about something else; which they'll try to do. Do not stop asking for evidence or demanding they look at evidence until they give you a clear reply such as: already looked at that, I reject it because blah, ... Force them to, at least, consider the evidence. Make it clear that if they want to move on to something else, they must first deal with your evidence. At the very least, they must tell you why they reject it.

3. Don't bother telling the left they are moral degenerates or anything like that. They'll find you incomprehensible. The reason they are the left is because they're morally superior to you (in their minds)! You can only win an argument about ethics/morality by presenting a careful argument which requires a discussion or a slideshow, or a video. Not bandying. Not labeling. You are allowed to make a side-snipe at the end: provided you already gave your evidence.

The World State [A True Story] | New Class

The World State [A True Story] | New Class by Martin Durkin time 0:00 In recent films, I've started to build an argument t...